Shake Shack's Top 5 Burgers: A Definitive Ranking for 2025

Shake Shack, born from a humble hot dog cart in Manhattan's Madison Square Park, has become a global burger phenomenon. Known for its high-quality ingredients, craveable ShackSauce, and commitment to 'Standing for Something Good,' Shake Shack offers a diverse menu that can sometimes feel overwhelming. So, which burgers truly stand out? As of 2025, here's a definitive ranking of the top 5 burgers you need to try.

Why Shake Shack?

Before diving in, let's address why Shake Shack earns such a loyal following. Several factors contribute to its popularity:

• Quality Ingredients: Shake Shack uses 100% Angus beef with no hormones or antibiotics. They are committed to humane treatment of animals.
• Freshness: Burgers are made with beef that has never been frozen.
• The ShackSauce: This proprietary blend of mayo, ketchup, and spices creates a unique and addictive flavor.
• Community Focus: Shake Shack actively supports local communities through donations and events.

However, some sources indicate that Shake Shack's burgers contain a high number of ingredients and preservatives.

The Ranking:

5. ShackBurger The classic for a reason. A single or double Angus beef patty topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and ShackSauce on a toasted potato bun. It's a solid, well-rounded burger that highlights the quality of Shake Shack's core ingredients. Many reviewers praise the ShackSauce as the key component. A single ShackBurger contains approximately 530 calories.

6. Bacon Cheeseburger Bacon makes everything better, right? Shake Shack's Bacon Cheeseburger delivers applewood-smoked bacon that adds a smoky depth to their classic cheeseburger. For an extra flavor boost, ask for extra ShackSauce.

7. SmokeShack This burger takes the bacon cheeseburger to the next level with the addition of chopped cherry peppers. The peppers provide a sweet and spicy kick that complements the smoky bacon and savory beef. The SmokeShack offers a balance of flavors and textures that make it a standout choice. It consists of a smashed burger patty, cheese, bacon, and pickled cherry peppers, plus Shack Sauce.

8. Avocado Bacon Burger A more recent addition that has quickly gained popularity. Creamy avocado slices and crispy applewood-smoked bacon combine for a California-inspired burger. The avocado adds a luxurious texture and balances the saltiness of the bacon. Some reviewers note the quality and freshness of the avocado as a key selling point.

9. Shack Stack For those who want it all, the Shack Stack combines a classic Angus beef patty with a 'Shroom Burger (a fried portobello mushroom filled with melted cheese). It's a vegetarian and meat-lover's dream. The combination of textures and flavors is undeniably indulgent. However, some find it overwhelming.

Honorable Mentions (Secret Menu)

Don't forget to explore Shake Shack's secret menu for even more unique creations:

• Peanut Butter & Bacon ShackBurger: A savory-sweet combination that was once on the regular menu. Order a ShackBurger with bacon and ask for peanut butter sauce on the side.
• Shack-Cago Burger: A Chicago-style burger with relish, onions, cucumbers, pickles, tomatoes, mustard, celery salt, and sport peppers.
• Protein Style Burger: Any burger can be ordered protein style, wrapped in lettuce instead of a bun.
• The Quad Burger: For serious meat lovers. Order any burger with four patties.

Final Thoughts

Shake Shack continues to innovate and offer high-quality burgers that appeal to a wide range of tastes. Whether you prefer a classic ShackBurger or a more adventurous SmokeShack, there's a burger on the menu for you. Don't be afraid to explore the secret menu and customize your order to create your perfect Shake Shack experience.